Bottles Left Behind After Buying a House: What to Do
How to assess condition, avoid scams, and submit photos safely when provenance is unknown.
Quick Answer
Finding a cellar in a new home is a common 'windfall' scenario. But without history, value depends entirely on condition.
- Don't move the bottles yet (keep them stable).
- Check if the cooling unit is actually working.
- Verify ownership (ensure it conveyed with the house).
- Take photos for a professional opinion.
- Sell quickly if you don't plan to maintain the climate control.
Identify if it is Trash or Treasure
Previous owners often leave behind 'junk' they didn't want to move. But sometimes they leave gems.
- Treasure Signs: Wooden crates, French labels (Bordeaux/Burgundy), vintage dates older than 2000.
- Trash Signs: Screw caps (mostly), jugs, vinegar smell in the room, grocery store brands.
Condition Liability
Since you didn't buy the wine, you don't know if the AC was off for a summer. Buyers will be cautious.
- Look for signs of seepage (sticky necks).
- Push corks (are they protruding?).
- We verify condition, but assume a 'risk discount' applies for unknown history.
Who Owns It?
Check your closing documents. Typically, personal property left after closing belongs to the buyer, but verify :
- Was the wine specifically excluded in the contract?
- Is there a post-occupancy agreement allowing them to retrieve items?
- If clear, you have the right to sell.
Common Mistakes
Ruining the find before selling.
- Turning off the cellar AC to save electricity.
- Moving bottles to the warm garage to 'clean up'.
- Trying to drink valuable old wine without preparing it (decanting).
What to Do Next
Turn the liability into cash.
- Keep the room dark and cool.
- Photograph the racks (don't unload everything yet).
- Send us the photos for a 'triage' assessment.
- We can organize a pickup if the value warrants it.
What to Do Next
Ready to get an offer for your bottles? Submit photos and details through our form, or text photos directly if that is easier.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the wine still good?
If the room feels cool (under 65°F), there is a good chance. If it feels like a normal room or hot, the wine may be cooked.
Can I sell it legally?
If you own the property and the contents, you can sell to a licensed buyer like us.
What if I find whiskey?
Whiskey is much more durable than wine. Even if stored warm, it is likely valuable and sellable.
Do you buy the racks?
No, we only buy the liquid assets.
How do I know what it is worth?
Submit photos. We give free valuations for collections.